This content has been generated using AI analysis. While we strive to ensure accuracy and quality, AI-generated material may occasionally contain errors or omissions. All information should be independently verified, and opinions expressed do not necessarily reflect those of the publishers or editors.
User reviews and community discussions of the Crowded House Deluxe Edition (SHM-CD) are limited in the available sources, with most feedback focusing on the 2016 standard 2CD deluxe reissues rather than the specific SHM-CD paper sleeve variant; sound quality receives the most criticism for heavy compression, while packaging and bonus content earn praise.
### Sound Quality
- Many reviewers describe the remasters as overly compressed and brickwalled, making them "unlistenable" or a "mess" despite high expectations for the band's catalog; some feel "ripped off" and prefer original CDs, which sound "nice" by comparison.
- Opinions vary: a minority find them enjoyable and "very clean," with "nice warmth" and fidelity close to originals, not unlistenable despite compression; one user notes the self-titled album has a "really fat mix" that "doesn't sound as old as it is."
- No direct mentions of SHM-CD sonics, but analogous vinyl remasters are praised for warmth on albums like *Together Alone*.
- Bonus material like demos and live tracks is highlighted positively, with "majestic" remastering polishing Paul Hester's contributions.
### Build Quality and Packaging
- Handsomely packaged in paperback-sized deluxe editions with band comments, artwork reconsideration, and "princely" presentation; unboxing videos emphasize high-quality physical sets.
- SHM-CD specifics unmentioned, but overall reissues lauded for extras like 21 bonus songs per album, including rarities, home demos, and live cuts.
### Reliability
- No reports of playback issues or defects; focus remains on mastering choices rather than disc durability.
### Strengths
- Exceptional bonus content: demos (e.g., Finn brothers' "palpable magic"), outtakes, B-sides, and live tracks like "Burglar's Song" add "breadth" and value, deemed a "godsend" for fans.
- Comprehensive campaign covering all seven albums, with "extraordinary" material and perfect compilation.
- Packaging and non-audio elements are "first-rate" and "highly respectful."
### Weaknesses
- Poor remastering due to excessive compression, influenced by modern styles (e.g., Radiohead); many skip reissues for originals.
- High expectations unmet for audio, overshadowing musical quality.
### Overall Reputation
- Polarized among fans: strong enthusiasm for content and packaging ("astounding achievement," "essential"), but sound issues lead some to pass or revert to originals; remains a "private passion" for dedicated listeners.
English (US)